Ask Jeremy @ MBAMission.com - What it takes to get to the best global business school

hi Jeremy,
Highly appreciate your fast and proactive action.
I will be grateful if you can reply 2 of my post above (or atleast one- bigger one).
Waiting for your insightful and honest opinion on my previous post.

thanks and Regds
HMG


Thanks for your advice regarding copying previous posts at the bottom. I apologize as a newbie pagal I am still learning the ropes. I have edited my previous posts to include the messages that I was responding to and will start to post all responses below my signature. Let me know if there is anything else that I can do to make life easier for you or anyone else in the community, with regard to proper communication.
Additionally, thank you for your patience with respect to my replies. I try to take the proper time to think about each answer and respond in depth, so, despite todays automatic response email world, I can, at times, take a day or two to get back to message boards.
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBA Mission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
hi jeremy,
Thanks for the efforts you are taking to Guide Guys like us.
I will be garetful if in your reply you can mention the name of the person whose post
you are replying. Its will be easier for us to follow up.

Thanks.
HMG
Vishal,
Thanks for your inquiry.
Clearly, your GMAT is quite strong. I have worked with Indian candidates before and know that engineering grades need to be viewed in relative terms, as a 60% can sometimes top the class. So, I would need more information in this regard.
Still, I think that you are going to find it difficult to get that coveted letter of acceptance, due to the fact that you have not only switched jobs but switched fields frequently. While you dont need to remain in one job or field, the schools like to see a clear path and clear upward trajectory. Further, what is it that you think differentiates you from all other Indian candidates, particularly professionally? With such a strong pool, how will you standout and capture the attention of the ultra-selective Admissions Committees at schools like Stanford and Harvard?
I think that LBS is a possibility, but if you are looking to American schools you might consider schools with strong Finance programs that are not as highly ranked NYU and Texas for example. I think that HBS, Chicago and Stanford will be reaches, unless I am missing something significant from your profile.
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBA Mission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype:MBAMission
Hi Jeremy,

I have posted this info on another thread also. However, I wanted to get your perspective on my profile and what else can I do to improve it.

Here is my profile :-

1. B.Tech - IITD - Civil Engg. - 6.24/10.0 (2003 passout)
2. GMAT - 780 (Q=50,V=47)
3. Work Ex: -

  1. Jun 2003 - Didn't get a job from campus. Searched on my own and joined a software company. Realised this is not what i want to do. Quit in Aug 2003
  2. Sep 2003 - Went back to a professor and started working in an R&D; center of Transportation Engg. Slowly got into econometrics and stuff. Quit in March 2004 coz my contract ended.
  3. Apr 2004 - Joined a small (30-35 ppl) Market Research company. Learned a lot there. Got promoted in 3 months. Had a leadership role as well. Quit in May 2005 coz reached saturation.
  4. June 2005 - Joined one of the biggest Credit Card company. Working in same analytics field. Build models, do statistical analysis.
4. I take out time from my job to go to a school for underprivileged children to teach.
5. I am aiming for Fall 2007 and want to do MBA in Finance.

I am planning to apply to Chicago, Stanford, Harvard and LBS.

Could you give your opinion about what these institutes look for and whether my profile is in synch with that?

Are there any other good schools for finance?

What are the weak points in my profile?

Would be really great if you could share your thoughts here.

Vishal
HMG,

Thanks for your inquiry.

In terms of improving your candidacy during a two year period, there is quite a lot that can be done. Industry best certifications can help, but the top-schools are more interested in the qualitative aspects of your profile the aspects that cannot be quantified. I would argue that, if you had to choose, you would be better off coaching a childrens basketball team for two years, but this, of course, does not need to be a trade-off. You could/can do both.

I constantly tell my clients, The application process is an art, not a science. GMAT scores, GPAs and certifications do not necessarily add up to an acceptance, particularly among your very competitive peer group. You will need to find ways through personal, community and professional experiences to differentiate yourself to achieve more and to have unique experiences. This is, of course, is easier said than done.

In terms of community activity, for example, you would benefit from being focused on two different organizations and making significant differences within them showing true leadership and leading change or growth. It is not enough to just volunteer regularly; you need to show that you have had your personal impact; you need to be able to prove to the admissions committees that everything you undertake is done with intensity of spirit and excellence. Generally speaking this should be true of your personal and professional life as well. You want to show the committee that you are constantly seeking opportunities and that when you seize them, you commit yourself to achieving the highest standards.

This is a pretty broad and philosophical answer. If you happen to have specific questions about choices that you are making -- organizations to join, career moves to make, etc. --please feel free to post again.

I am sorry for what you perceived to be a delay in my response. I try to be as thoughtful as possible and sometimes it takes to craft a detailed response. With time, I will get to everyone!

Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission

www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
hi Jeremy,
Thanks for the Initiative taken for PGs. I want to ask one generic question.
This will be applicable to almost all MBA aspirants.
I am planning to do MBA in next 1-2 year from Ivy collegs either in India/US/Europe.
I am from IT sector with a 'not-so-good' college. My question is how i can improve my profile in order to make myself equip for applying to ivy league colleges keeping in mind that my academic college is not so good.
Few of the things i am doing is:
1. Industry best certifications - I just completed my project Mgt certification from PMI.
Now doing oracle ERP certification ( as i am working as Tech consultant in ERP domain).
2. few Extra Curriculars like Joining Public speaking club.

I have 3 yrs of IT experience and i am MCA. By the time i will join MBA college i will have around 4-5 yrs of exp.
So i have 1-2 yrs with me to improve my profile and get to the level where i can apply for TOP MBA colleges. I need your valuable suggestions /Tips on how i can improve my profile.

Thanks abd Regds,
HMG

Hello Jeremy,
Thanks a lot for helping us out with your valuable insights. I'd request you to evaluate my profile and let me know whether i make a possible fit for the schools i am looking at.

  1. Acads: BE (Electronics and communication) from a "locally" well know colege - scored 80.75%, which gets converted to a 3.7 GPA. (The topper has a 87.5%)
  2. GMAT: 750 (Q50, V41)
  3. Work ex: 3 yrs (will be 4 by fall 2007) with a software company (HCL Technologies) as a developer.
  4. Extra currics: Pretty good in sports and arts. Represented college in 2 diff games at varsity level. Member of many literary societies and art clubs in college.
  5. Leadership skills: Have good record in both College and work place.
  6. Community Service: Member of service groups in college. Was involved in the recent tsunami rehabilitation work. Also involved in some work with school students.
I'm targeting a finance profile post MBA , with touches of entrepreneurship/general-management. The schools i am planning to apply at are Wharton, Stanford, Chicago, Columbia, London, HBS, Tuck. Schools like Duke, Stern, Yale, Kellogg, UCLA are all on the second list - dunno how many i'd apply. Wud like to get it done with round 1 itself.

Please let me know how big a drawback, if at all, is my lack of relevant experience. I am reading material to learn Finance and related concepts, but i agree it would not equate to the kind of stuff a fin student learns thru college.

Is there any other weakness in my candidature which i'm missing to see? Is there any other data which os necessary for you to analyse my profile? Please let me know your views - they will be really helpful.

thanks,
Iday
As an addendum to my post on what you can do to prepare for the coming year, I have attached a series that I wrote over the last few weeks on this very topic, only it was targeted at those applying this year. Still, the series should be entirely valid, only with adjustments implied for the timing of certain events.
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
During the next few weeks, I will be posting a series helping to prepare applicants for the coming year. Topics will include:
- Scheduling/Application milestones
- Enhancing your community profile
- Developing your personal profile
- Visiting schools/networking with alums and students
- Cultivating relationships with recommenders
- Selecting additional coursework
- Resume Preparation
- Reviewing existing applications
- Short answer completion
- Firm sponsorship
- Adding professional dimensions/accelerating professional goals
Feel free to ask for any additions to the series that are of relevance to you.
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
The following is the second in a series of postings on preparation for the coming year.
Establishing Application Milestones
While there are still seven months until next years first round deadlines pass, there may in fact be less time to prepare than prospective applicants might imagine. Many candidates do not contemplate how daunting it can be to start the application process in September, especially those who have their eyes on October deadlines. Suddenly, you could face the task of tackling the GMAT, writing many different essays for five or six different schools, drafting a resume, selecting and managing recommenders and completing campus visits -- all at once. If that is not enough, you will still have to continue with existing commitments to your employer, community and family. The difference between completing your ideal number of applications and a reduced, manageable number might be the difference between starting to prepare now and starting in the summer or fall.
GMAT Complete by June
The GMAT is clearly the most stressful piece of the puzzle that can be taken care of at your discretion. The benefits of taking the GMAT soon are twofold, you have a solid understanding of where you will be competitive and, again, the test is out of the way. Most candidates prepare for several months for the GMAT and it is important to leave time to retake the test just in case your score is not as high as you had hoped. The bottom line is that it is best to be studying for the GMAT in isolation -- not while writing your essays; I recommend that my candidates complete the GMAT by the end of June, leaving you April, May and June to study get started.
Resume Complete by July
Additionally, as you take breaks from your GMAT study or possibly between taking your test and the release of essay questions by your school of choice, it is wise to take the time to update your resume. Aside from the satisfaction that comes with completing this piece of the puzzle, your resume can be a solid starting point for brainstorming about your professional essays and considering your accomplishments in greater depth. Of course, your most recent entry for your existing job will need to be reviewed and possibly updated near the deadline, but, again, this is a small step in a much larger process that will ultimately relieve some pressure on you. Again, the goal is to only have essays to write as of July. (Resume drafting will be explored in greater depth as part of this series.)
Community Service Start now
If you have not yet begun making a commitment to your community, now is certainly the time to get started. With seven months until the first round deadline, you still have time to make a significant contribution to an organization and not run into the credibility problems that occur when you start volunteering two months before the deadline. Furthermore, you dont want to be making up for lost time in your community, just as you are about to tackle five applications. Unfortunately, six months ago was a better time to start getting involved, but right now you are nearing the limit for what is suspicious with respect to next year. (Community service will be explored in greater depth as part of this series.)
Knowledge Gathering Start now
Now is also the time to begin understanding the differences between the MBA programs. Even though most schools Class Visit programs have ended for the year, you can still learn about programs via rankings, school websites, message boards and, most importantly, by talking to current students and alumni. There are significant differences from program to program, as a result of pedagogy, class size, locations, strength of alumni base, professional specializations, facilities, professors and firms that recruit on campus. By educating yourself about each schools unique offerings, you will be able to make a stronger case for yourself and your fit with a particular school. (Networking will be explored in greater depth as part of this series.)
Supplementary Classes Complete by August (at the latest)
Start time and intensities of supplemental courses such as calculus or financial accounting vary according to the institution offering them. Thus, it is difficult to advise on a broad basis how to time these classes. Preferably, you can take these classes in isolation, so that you can focus on the GMAT and essay writing exclusively. However, if you cannot avoid some overlap, it is better to take a class while studying for the GMAT as the increased numerical exposure can help improve your test score. While you may not be able to control the end dates of the class, it is best to have these classes completed before the essay questions are released and if this is not possible, at the end of summer session (August) at the latest.
Conclusion
There is certainly no need to panic, but the clock is ticking. By taking some important steps now, you can reduce the pressure next fall and thus increase your chances of gaining admission to the school of your choice.
The following is the second in a series of postings on preparation for the coming year.
Enhancing Your Community Profile
As I noted in my previous post on Establishing Application Milestones, if you have not yet become involved in a community organization, now is the time to get started. If you start to volunteer in September, your gesture will seem far less sincere and you will lack the track record to credibly discuss your experiences in your essays.
When considering volunteer activities, you should first and foremost become involved in an organization about which you feel passionately. If you are excited about your volunteer experience, you will be more committed, have a more profound experience and will have a far more genuine story to tell.
Ideally, you will have a record of community experience that complements and supplements your profile: the accountant who volunteers with Junior Achievement is complementing his existing profile, showing a commitment to his professional path and the desire to give back in this area; the accountant who coaches soccer in his community is supplementing his profile in that he is offering a new window into his profile and personality. Your community activities have the power to show a true passion for your field (complementary) or enhance the committees perspective (supplementary) and thus differentiate you from many others.
In the example above, I use Junior Achievement and Soccer Coaching to illustrate my point; while a solid commitment to any organization will be helpful to your candidacy, the more esoteric the organization, the more distinct you become. While you should not volunteer in a completely obscure organization just to be different, if you are truly passionate about both soccer and antiquities preservation, you should consider volunteering in the latter field, thus increasing your opportunities to discuss this unusual hobby/interest. Regardless of the organization and the nature of your activities, if you can (to cart out a clich) make a difference within your organization and show true leadership in doing so, you should be able to add an entirely new dimension to your application.
The following is the third in a series of postings on preparing for the coming year.
Developing Your Personal Profile
Similar to your community endeavors, personal achievements enable you to differentiate yourself from the indistinguishable masses. While every candidate has his/her work experience and academics, you can offer a far more diversified and remarkable picture of yourself through volunteer and personal accomplishments.
In terms of personal achievements, you should focus on accelerating the timeline of existing endeavors. If you have always intended to publish a certain article and are almost finished a final draft, then finish it. If you have always intended to complete the CFA and only have level three left, take the final test this year. If you can run twenty miles and have always dreamed of running the marathon, then run it this year. I am not suggesting that if you have never run a mile in your life that you start training for the marathon now; I am suggesting that if a goal is in sight and it will be otherwise achieved, you accelerate your timeline and ensure that you have completed it before the first round deadline.
Beyond the examples above, other areas of personal accomplishment include language study (achieving fluency), adventure travel (completing a certain hike/climb, etc), professional and extra-curricular certifications (CA, EMT, etc) and more. Many candidates often exclusively pursue community activity in the months before their applications, but personal opportunities can also significantly affect your profile and separate you from the field.
hi Jeremy,
Thanks for the Initiative taken for PGs. I want to ask one generic question.
This will be applicable to almost all MBA aspirants.
I am planning to do MBA in next 1-2 year from Ivy collegs either in India/US/Europe.
I am from IT sector with a 'not-so-good' college. My question is how i can improve my profile in order to make myself equip for applying to ivy league colleges keeping in mind that my academic college is not so good.
Few of the things i am doing is:
1. Industry best certifications - I just completed my project Mgt certification from PMI.
Now doing oracle ERP certification ( as i am working as Tech consultant in ERP domain).
2. few Extra Curriculars like Joining Public speaking club.

I have 3 yrs of IT experience and i am MCA. By the time i will join MBA college i will have around 4-5 yrs of exp.
So i have 1-2 yrs with me to improve my profile and get to the level where i can apply for TOP MBA colleges. I need your valuable suggestions /Tips on how i can improve my profile.

Thanks abd Regds,
HMG

(Well, a post should not exceed 15000 characters, so here is much of the rest in another frame...)

The following is the fourth in a series of postings on preparing for the coming year.
Visiting Campuses and Networking with Students and Alumni
As I have noted in previous posts, it would be ideal for you as a prospective candidate to have nothing but your applications to manage come July (when most applications are released). While many take their GMAT and TOEFL exams by June in order to focus on their essays starting in July, few realize that there is a tremendous opportunity to visit campuses now -- both to learn about specific programs of choice and to ensure that the fall schedule is not too busy. It is difficult enough for many candidates to manage their professional, personal and community lives; the addition of five class visits in five different cities during a one or two month span can often be stressful and too much to manage.
Many schools (Stanford, HBS, Chicago, Kellogg, etc) still have campus visit programs that are in place until the end of their respective academic years and some offer visits throughout the summer, depending on their academic calendars. By visiting several of your schools of choice now, you will not only save yourself the stress in the fall, but you will also benefit from the visit itself.
Campus visits are not just checked boxes for the admissions committee, but are tremendous opportunities for you to gain an intimate understanding of various academic methodologies and academic and social environments. While your campus visits may help you choose which schools to apply to, they will also help you frame your thoughts and write far more personal essays. There is only so much that you can learn about a school via its website. Your campus visit will enable you to experience the true character of your MBA program of choice and then discuss your connection to it in a profound way. You can express a certain sincerity, if you can write about your personal interactions with professors and students as a catalyst for your decision to apply to a certain school.
Similarly, by meeting with any alumni or current students that you may know, you can gain a more intimate understanding of your school of choice. Current students in particular will have an awareness of specific programs and classes that may not hold a prominent place on their schools websites, but may be quite appealing to you and may enable you to strengthen your case for attending a certain school. By meeting with students and alumni and visiting classes and taking thorough notes on your experience, you will have a variety of data points which will help serve as a foundation for you to persuade the admissions committees that their school is most suitable for you, in a way that few others will be able to compare.
If you do not have connections with current students and alumni, you can politely contact current students who are heads of the clubs that are of interest to you and ask them for a few moments to discuss their schools attributes. If you aspire to be an entrepreneur for example, speaking with the President of the Entrepreneurship Club will enable you to quickly understand the various offerings at your school of choice and may even result in your finding an advocate for your candidacy.
The following is the fifth in a series of postings on preparing for the coming year.
Cultivating Relationships with Recommenders
While you may be like many others, worrying about your recommenders titles, what is far more important is that you select an individual who knows what is demanded of a recommender. Recommenders need to write very personal and intimate letters, discussing your talents, accomplishments, personality and potential. If the President of your firm can only discuss your work in vague and general terms, he/she will not help your cause. Conversely, if an Associate who is senior to you and supervises your work can offer powerful examples of the impact you have had on your company, he/she will help your cause far more.
As you contemplate those who you will select, try to gather some intelligence on your potential recommenders. Has he/she written letters for anyone else? Is he/she generous with his/her time when it comes to employee feedback and review sessions? Generally speaking, is your superior a good supervisor/boss? One of the best windows into your potential process will be previous colleagues, who you may even want to speak to discover how your supervisor managed the process. By identifying those who will be helpful and generous, you will alleviate the potential stress of missed deadlines and unpredictable letters.
While you should spend time right now doing your homework on your recommenders, another important step that you can take is getting in touch with previous supervisors with whom you have fallen out of contact. You do not want to be in a position where you are calling a former supervisor for the first time in years and asking him for a massive favor on a tight timeline. If you can identify a former supervisor whose time you will be needing, then make contact now and keep the relationship warm for the next few months. You will be far better off when the letter writing process begins.
You need to be careful in terms of who you ask to write on your behalf, especially when you are contemplating someone from your past. Certain individuals, such as military commanders, can often provide very valuable feedback, even if their experience with you was from years ago. Again, in the case of a former commander, you may need to locate him/her or warm that relationship up, after years of it being dormant. Under very particular circumstances, certain coaches and professors may also offer unique insight into your candidacy; but again, you may need to spend some time locating them and re-establishing your connection. Now is the time to make your connections; come September, it might be too late.
The following is the sixth in a series of postings on preparing for the coming year.
Selecting Additional Coursework
MBA programs are far more forgiving of previous academic problems than virtually any other graduate discipline. For most, their academic experience is far in the past and their GMAT, references and work experience are better indicators of their potential for success. This is not to suggest that poor grades dont matter; this is to suggest, however, that poor grades can be mitigated.
If your academic performance is worrisome to you, you should certainly consider enrolling in some additional coursework immediately. In particular, if you did poorly in math courses (even if your overall GPA is quite high), this will raise concerns about your ability to manage a heavily quantitative workload. Thus, you should consider a calculus, statistic or linear algebra class. Furthermore, in order to show an aptitude for management studies, you might want to consider taking an accounting, economics or corporate finance class. Needless to write, it is quite important that you get As in these courses to show not only that you have the aptitude but also that you have matured and take your academics quite seriously.
It is important to remember that additional coursework is not solely the domain of the academically challenged. Even those who did quite well in their undergrad classes might explore the option of taking additional coursework. Liberal Arts majors with 4.0s and no quantitative background can benefit from two As -- one in a math discipline one in a management discipline enabling them to make a strong statement about their competencies for their coming studies.
Again, you do not want to be going to classes while writing essays and applying to a variety of schools. So, it is important that you understand what is available to you and do your utmost to get these courses done before the applications become available in July, if that is still possible in your area.
The following is the seventh in a series of postings on preparing for the coming year.
Resume Preparation
Throughout this series, I have repeated a simple mantra get anything and everything (class visits, coursework, GMAT exams, etc.) done now so that you can focus on your applications come July. Your resume can be constructed now and the final update to your most recent position can be added in October during the latest stages of the process. Aside from the obvious timing benefits in completing your resume now, you will also benefit from reflecting on your accomplishments, a process that will help you brainstorm essay ideas and enable you to remind your recommenders of your major achievements.
As you strive to write a standout resume, you should think to yourself, What are my accomplishments? not What were my responsibilities? By re-hashing your responsibilities, you will essentially be offering only the most basic information on your position. Many candidates choose to write something like: Responsible for managing $10M media campaign, supervising staff of five junior brand managers, monitoring daily sales volumes and ensuring consistent supply of product from five production facilities in three countries. The problem with stating responsibilities is that the reader has no understanding of whether this individual is effective in his/her position. Was the media campaign successful? Did the staff of five progress? Did sales volumes increase? Did the supply of products reach its destination?
By breaking each of these bullet points down, elaborating on each task and then showing clear consequences of these actions, the reader learns of your decisive maneuvers and, more importantly, your results.
Instead of responsible for managing $10M media campaign offer more details on the task:
Initiated $10M television/internet Island Vacation promotion to introduce new Shine brand detergent
Then, offer clear results of your efforts
surpassing first year sales targets in three months.
By following an action/results formula, you will offer the reader a consistent record of success and show that you have excelled in your work, which is of course, your goal for your resume.
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission

hi Jeremy,
Thanks for the Initiative taken for PGs. I want to ask one generic question.
This will be applicable to almost all MBA aspirants.
I am planning to do MBA in next 1-2 year from Ivy collegs either in India/US/Europe.
I am from IT sector with a 'not-so-good' college. My question is how i can improve my profile in order to make myself equip for applying to ivy league colleges keeping in mind that my academic college is not so good.
Few of the things i am doing is:
1. Industry best certifications - I just completed my project Mgt certification from PMI.
Now doing oracle ERP certification ( as i am working as Tech consultant in ERP domain).
2. few Extra Curriculars like Joining Public speaking club.

I have 3 yrs of IT experience and i am MCA. By the time i will join MBA college i will have around 4-5 yrs of exp.
So i have 1-2 yrs with me to improve my profile and get to the level where i can apply for TOP MBA colleges. I need your valuable suggestions /Tips on how i can improve my profile.

Thanks abd Regds,
HMG
(After another 15000 characters, the series concludes...)

The following is the eighth in a series of postings on preparing for the coming year.
Reviewing Existing Applications
A simple exercise that can be quite helpful in addressing your strengths and weaknesses is reviewing previous applications to programs that you are certain you will apply to in the future. While the essays may change in the coming year, you can still learn a great deal by reviewing the questions and anticipating how you might have answered them in the past. By contemplating your profile, you should come to a better understanding of your distinctiveness and marketability and target areas for improvement.
For example, HBS had seven essay questions this year:
1. What would you like the MBA Admissions Board to know about your undergraduate academic experience? (400-word limit)
2. What are your three most substantial accomplishments and why do you view them as such? (600-word limit)
3. Discuss a defining experience in your development as a leader. (400-word limit)
4. In your career, you will have to deal with many ethical issues. What are likely to be the most challenging and what is your plan for developing the competencies you will need to handle these issues effectively? (400-word limit)
5. What are your strengths and weaknesses as a leader? (400-word limit)
6. What are your career aspirations and how can an MBA help you to reach them? Why now? (400-word limit)
7. What do you wish the MBA Admissions Board had asked you? (400-word limit)
After taking some time to consider your answers to these (or any other schools) essay questions, try to consider whether you are offering a diverse picture of your own experiences; try to understand whether you are able to offer something new and interesting in each essay; try to understand the entirety of your profile. It is possible that if you are lacking certain dimensions, repeat certain stories or are forced to place too much emphasis on one area of your life, you can target certain weaknesses and improve upon them going forward by taking on new activities (see Msg 5733.1134, 5733.1140).
The following is the ninth in a series of postings on preparing for the coming year.
Short Answer Completion
Throughout this series, I have focused on freeing candidates from all other constraints so that they can pay careful attention to their essays come January. Short answers the small sections within the actual application forms themselves which pertain to your work history, community accomplishments, scholarships and criteria, etc. do not change much from year to year. While many choose to put-off these details you can rid yourself of a headache now by taking the time to complete these sections. Furthermore, similar in benefit to your resume, by completing this step early on, you may contemplate and discover stories that will be quite useful in writing your essays.
An abbreviated version of HBSs short answer on work history (which actually did change slightly last year) follows:
Job Description:
Job Title:
Your Responsibilities: (200 characters only)
Key Accomplishments: (200 characters only)
Most Significant Challenge: (200 characters only)
Reason for Leaving: (200 characters only)
Again, if you need to complete these forms thoughtfully for several positions and then complete several other similar sections for your volunteer and extra-curricular experiences, this can be time consuming as you approach the deadlines. By completing them now, for all of your applications, you will have a brainstorming tool in hand and a small obstacle out of the way.
The following is the tenth and final posting on a series about preparing for the coming year.
Firm Sponsorship
Firm sponsored candidates are quite appealing to Admissions Committees as the committee knows that they will be employed upon graduation and that their post-MBA goals are within reach. Furthermore, the Admissions Committee will sleep better at night, knowing that their BusinessWeek responses will see a small statistical benefit in the percentage of candidates employed upon graduation and possibly even average starting salary categories. Firm sponsorship is frequently an asset.
I have worked with unsponsored clients, of course, but I have also worked with many clients who have been unaware that their firms do sponsor employees. For that sake, I have worked with clients whose firms did not have sponsorship programs, but created them when our candidates brought forth the idea.
So, first things first, you need to discover if your firm has such a program and then if they do, you need to learn all you can about the process for earning a firm scholarship. I have worked with international clients who have needed to apply internally 1.5 years before their proposed program would begin; obviously, in such a case, you do not want to be applying at the last moment. Similarly, if you are going to invent your companys program, this might take months of bureaucratic haggling and decision making. This is certainly a process that you should start now.
hi Jeremy,
Thanks for the Initiative taken for PGs. I want to ask one generic question.
This will be applicable to almost all MBA aspirants.
I am planning to do MBA in next 1-2 year from Ivy collegs either in India/US/Europe.
I am from IT sector with a 'not-so-good' college. My question is how i can improve my profile in order to make myself equip for applying to ivy league colleges keeping in mind that my academic college is not so good.
Few of the things i am doing is:
1. Industry best certifications - I just completed my project Mgt certification from PMI.
Now doing oracle ERP certification ( as i am working as Tech consultant in ERP domain).
2. few Extra Curriculars like Joining Public speaking club.

I have 3 yrs of IT experience and i am MCA. By the time i will join MBA college i will have around 4-5 yrs of exp.
So i have 1-2 yrs with me to improve my profile and get to the level where i can apply for TOP MBA colleges. I need your valuable suggestions /Tips on how i can improve my profile.

Thanks abd Regds,
HMG
My Profile

1. 2004 Batch Electrical Engineer from a Top Ten 10 Enginnering College. 3.6GPA. Top 10 in class.

2. First Job : L&T; : Product Marketing Executive. Started as Graduate Engineering trainee, got promoted to Executive Leadership Cadre in 1 year itself. Looked after a newly launched product.

Present Job : Schneider Electric : Sales Engineer, look after entire Mumbai Industry. Will be promoted to Sr. Sales Engineer next year. Youngest person with such a profile in the company.

Widely travelled in India.Almost all business districts. Total exp today: 2 years. In 2008: 3.5years

3. Loads of Extra curriculars in College : Class representative, Secretary of 2 College Clubs, Member of Students Union, Editor of College Mazagine etc.

4. Should manage 720+ in GMAT. Taking it in Dec.

5. Looking at colleges to shift to MC. Looking at Darden/Kellog/IESE/Insead-Singapore.

6. Financial Aid a MUST with no cosigner.

7.Community Service : Only in college.

Looking at fall 2008 admit.Request you to please advice on Colleges to consider and how to go about the process effectively.

Regards
Thanks for your inquiry.

You wrote 2.9/3, did you mean 2.9/4? Still, even if your GPA is low, that was eight years ago and you could make the case that there are better indicators with regard to your abilities and capacity for future success (recommendations, GMAT, etc.)

Your age is an obstacle, but there is nothing that you can do about this, so you will have to work with it. You will have to emphasize your experience as a decision maker and your international experience in East Africa; in simple terms, you will need to show that you are not applying because you are bored and old, but that you are applying now because your career was fascinating, you were a leader and you did not have time to take a breath until now.

Similarly, you should have very clear goals going forward you need to make clear that your best years are ahead of you and that this MBA will make your future goals a reality. More so than with younger candidates, you will really need to have vision and ambition. You cant get away with I want to go into General Management. It is just too vague; the school would rather invest in a younger candidate who has the time to climb the ranks.

I think that Stanford is unrealistic for you and Yale, with its small class, might be quite difficult as well. You might find a spot at Darden or Fuqua, but this really depends on how much leadership you have had in your workplace and whether you can wow the adcom with these experiences.

Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission

www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
Hello Jeremy,

I am looking to apply to a few top-tier general management schools in the US for the class of 2009. My my post MBA plans would be General management/strategy - I know this is a broad swath but I will firm up future plans in my essays.

- Indian, male age 32
- Undergrad and Masters degrees in Economics from top colleges in India. Undergrad GPA is approx 2.9/3.0. Masters 3.6
- GMAT 690, 91 % ile
- 8 years work experience with a relatively small firm. started as a trainee. presently manage a division, and am in the 2nd tier of decision making in my company. Middle management leadership projects - have made an impact on my organization
- Should be able to secure good recos from senior management at work
- Brief overseas assignments in the US and East Africa (6 months each)
- Extensive overseas travel and my work involves dealing with associates worldwide on a daily basis
- Community : Some during college, and 1-2 work sponsored programs that I have been involved in. Nothing above and beyond.
- Target schools : Darden, Fuqua, Yale SOM, Stanford

Questions :
1. I would really appreciate your comments with regard to my profile, chances and fit. Also, are any of these schools here a reach for me?

2. I think my Graduate GPA should be good enough, but is my undergrad GPA going to be a hinderance?

3. Is the lack of work experience with a multinational i.e blue chip experience going to work against me?

Sorry if this has turned to be long, but I thought I d give you as much information as possible. I be glad for any assistance that you d be able to provide.

V.
A variety of questions about the HBS MBA and the MBA itself are pondered in the New York Times. Worth the read
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
June 11, 2006
Was Earning That Harvard M.B.A. Worth It?
By ABBY ELLIN
ABOUT a year before Adam Richman was to graduate from the Harvard Business School in 1996, he took on an extracurricular project. It was long before the Internet bubble inflated and burst, and well before one of the school's graduates landed in the White House. Mr. Richman wondered: What was the real-world value of a master's in business administration, especially one from the iviest of Ivies? Was it, as widely perceived, an ace in the hole, a get-out-of-jail-free card, a ticket to the good life?
To that end, Mr. Richman decided to track a core group of his Harvard classmates, to converse with them about their personal and professional aspirations, and then to revisit them every five years until 2026. He also decided to film them along the way, la "7 Up," Michael Apted's celebrated documentary series, which chronicled the lives of the same 14 people every seven years.
"I wanted to know how students made their career and leadership decisions, how they defined success," said Mr. Richman, 36, the co-founder of Double Nickel Entertainment, a television and film production company. His academic adviser, Monica C. Higgins, an associate professor at the business school, became a consultant for the series, titled "Building Career Foundations," which she uses for case-study work in her classroom.
"We're very interested in how external shocks affect careers like 9/11, the dot-com boom and bust and this class was right before the dot-com boom," said Professor Higgins, 41. "We wondered: 'How do people make the decision to drop everything and go after a dream? Who makes those type of choices and why?' People ask alums, 'What was the most important class you took in school?' But the real test comes once you're out."
In that regard, their documentary is a litmus test of sorts about how much bang Harvard Business School graduates get for their buck after their academic sojourn to Boston. It is, of course, a narrow, microcosmic gauge, limited by the number of people Mr. Richman and Professor Higgins are following, the questions they ask and the complexities of education and personal choice.
Even so, their work offers a window into the value of a Harvard degree that carries a two-year tuition bill of more than $70,000 and, more generally, onto the overall utility of any M.B.A. degree.
THE popularity of the degrees has surged. In 1970, for example, business schools handed out 26,490 M.B.A.'s, according to the Department of Education. By 2004, after a period marked by an economic boom and heightened competition for top-flight business careers, that figure had jumped to 139,347. But opinion and data appear divided on the tangible benefits of an M.B.A.
"The M.B.A. is the most versatile degree out there most of the others are very field specific, but you can apply an M.B.A. to any field," said Rachel Edgington, a research director for the Graduate Management Admission Council, a nonprofit group in McLean, Va., that is overseen by leading business schools and administers annual admission exams.
But others advocate hands-on experience over academic buffing and polishing. "M.B.A. programs train the wrong people in the wrong ways with the wrong consequences," said Henry Mintzberg, a management professor at McGill University in Montreal. "You can't create a manager in a classroom. If you give people who aren't managers the impression that you turned them into one, you've created hubris."
In 2003, Professor Mintzberg tracked the performance of 19 students who graduated from the Harvard Business School in 1990 and were at the top of their class academically. Ten of the 19 were "utter failures," he said. "Another four were very questionable, at least," he added. "So five out of 19 did well."
Research varies on the value of an M.B.A. A 2006 study by the Lubin School of Business at Pace University, looking at 482 companies listed on the New York Stock Exchange, found that only 162 of them had chief executives with graduate degrees in business. The companies with chief executives who went to more prestigious schools did no better than those who went to less prestigious schools, according to the study. Why this was so is unclear.
"One possibility is that if you don't have a graduate degree from a top school then you have to work that much harder to succeed," said Aron A. Gottesman, an associate professor at Pace and a co-author of the study.
On the other hand, Professor Gottesman and a colleague found in a separate study, published earlier this year in the Journal of Empirical Finance, that mutual fund managers with M.B.A.'s from BusinessWeek's 30 top-ranked business schools including Harvard generally outperformed other mutual fund managers. Professor Gottesman is not sure why this was so, either. "One possibility is that at higher-quality schools they simply teach better technical skills," he speculated. "Or students at top-tier schools have a higher I.Q."
Wherever the broader value of an M.B.A. degree resides, most graduates themselves appear to be satisfied with their diplomas. According to the 2006 Global M.B.A. Graduate Survey from the Graduate Management Admission Council, 63 percent of M.B.A. alumni described the value of their degree as "outstanding or excellent," when comparing the cost of their degree to the quality of their educations; 29 percent called it "good."
And the subjects of "Building Career Foundations" have told Mr. Richman that they are pleased, indeed, with the professional and personal doors that their Harvard degrees have opened. Mr. Richman and Professor Higgins initially chose four women and six men to be their subjects in 1996 after a lengthy interview process. They surveyed about 130 other students along with their main focus group, asking questions about post-Harvard goals, salary expectations, relationship status and other topics. They also sent similar questionnaires to the same people in 2001 and had their cameras ready to film their core group.
Last weekend, when the class of 1996 returned to the Harvard Business School for its 10-year reunion, Mr. Richman and Professor Higgins were present with their cameras and notepads.
"The experience lets you handle challenges, gives you the confidence to take calculated risks and enables people to pursue passions or dreams that maybe they otherwise couldn't at that point in their life," said Terrence M. Mullen, 39, a subject of the documentary who is a co-founder of Arsenal Capital Partners, a private equity fund in Manhattan.
In 1996 and 2001, Mr. Richman and Professor Higgins asked their 140 subjects how they defined success. Their answers, in descending order of importance, were the same in each of those years: personal satisfaction or "balance," the respect of their peers, and the chief executive's or chief financial officer's post at a corporation. High salaries ranked last each year.
"It did surprise me that the folks coming right out of school would put money last, because they had all this debt," Professor Higgins said. "But they want to have it all."
Respondents to her survey this year offered a different mix of priorities. They said that balance, financial security and corporate power were their top goals, but they placed less emphasis on becoming C.E.O.'s and were more interested in general corporate leadership positions. Ranked last was "respect by peers." Another category that often emerged, Professor Higgins said, was "impact" defined as making "a real difference" or "a positive difference to society."
Professor Higgins said the focus on "balance" and "happiness" seemed to stem from having or planning to have children, from feelings about the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, and from the bursting of the dot-com bubble. "They seemed to have come to realize that certain things are precious in life, not the least of which is family," she said.
At this year's reunion of the documentary's main subjects, it turned out that 6 of the 10 had been involved in Internet businesses previously four as C.E.O.'s of their own companies, and two as investors in other companies. Five of the 10 had experienced a major career trauma their businesses collapsed or were taken over or they lost jobs because of layoffs. The other five had invested successfully or cashed in on initial public offerings in companies where they had worked.
The documentary's main subjects now have jobs in various fields. Stephen Klein is executive vice president of Too Far, an arts and entertainment company in San Francisco; Kevin Hall is the chief operating officer of the Broad Foundation, a Los Angeles nonprofit group; Kim Malone is director of online advertising sales for Google Adsense in Mountain View, Calif.; Mareva Grabowski is a bank executive in Athens; Jeff Flemings is a senior executive at Digitas, an advertising and consulting firm in Boston; Clare R. Scherrer is a managing director at Goldman Sachs in New York; Levent Kahraman is a managing director of a New York bank; Cheryl Pegues is the director of business development at Cox Enterprises in Atlanta; and Humphrey Chen is a director at Avaya, a software company in Basking Ridge, N.J.
(articles continues)
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBA Mission

www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype:MBAMission



MR. HALL, 39, pursued a series of corporate jobs after getting his Harvard degree and then founded a company that ran charter schools. At the Broad Foundation, he focuses on improving public education in Los Angeles. "September 11 really reinforced for me that I'm willing and want to devote my energy toward K through 12 from a patriotic standpoint," he said. "I think it's really critical for us as a country to do this."

Mr. Richman, who was a creative writing and drama major when he graduated from TuftsUniversity in 1992, later went to HarvardBusinessSchool without formal business training and no plans to seek a corporate job. He did, however, want to do something in television and film, and rather than start as a gofer in Hollywood he applied to business school to "round myself off," he said.

"When I first got out, people in Hollywood were like: 'Why did you get your M.B.A.? You would have been better off sitting at someone's desk answering phones,' " he recalled. "But it certainly has been helpful for me now that we're doing bigger deals. It was helpful even before I started my company, putting together financing for projects and closing deals."

Another benefit of an M.B.A. degree, especially from a top-notch school, is the public perception of it - and, by default, its holder - according to a 2005 report by the University of Maryland. The study found that recruiters paid higher salaries to graduates of top-tier business schools compared with those from less prominent ones. "The school's prominence provides legitimacy in the eyes of third parties," said Violina P. Rindova, an associate professor of strategy at the University of Maryland and co-author of the study.

"The real value of an Ivy League business degree is arguably not the education itself, but the screening of intelligence, drive and past accomplishments that the schools do," said Ben Dattner, founding principal of Dattner Consulting in New York. "Just like with undergraduate degrees, if you're smart enough to get into a top-tier school, you're likely to inspire confidence."

MICHELLE MADDEN, 39, a 1994 HarvardBusinessSchool graduate who lives in New York and worked at an online media company which she and her partners sold in 2001, agrees. "People tend to give you the benefit of the doubt that you're somewhat intelligent," she said. "They assume that if H.B.S. has done the screening, they don't need to concern themselves with the intelligence screener."

The degree also gave Ms. Madden the confidence to leave the business world several years ago to pursue interests in photography and mountain climbing before resuming work as a consultant. "Today, there's much less of a stigma to taking time off and changing careers," she said. "With the M.B.A., I felt I could do it and return to work without much problem."

Others say that they preferred actually being an entrepreneur to just contemplating becoming one. Jamie Rosen, who quit HarvardBusinessSchool in 1995 after getting funding for a software start-up, sold his company in 2004 and founded Memorystone Publishing, a company that produces digital photo albums, a year later.

"The reason I went to B-school was to learn to be an entrepreneur, and here was an opportunity to build a business and get paid for it," said Mr. Rosen, 35, of his decision to leave Harvard. "I'm not necessarily happy that I didn't finish, but I don't regret not going back because I enjoyed what I was doing."

Ms. Malone, one of the subjects of Mr. Richman's documentary, said she never expected to enjoy Harvard as much as she did. "I went in with great skepticism," she said with a laugh. But what Ms. Malone, 38, found at Harvard surprised her - "a pretty friendly, warm, welcoming, nice place."

After Harvard, Ms. Malone spent a year working at the Federal Communications Commission and then helped begin an Internet telephone start-up, which eventually went public. She quit in 1999 to write her first novel, as yet unpublished, before joining Google in June 2004. Like Ms. Madden, Ms. Malone said her degree allowed her to take time off while knowing that it would be easy to get another job.

"It's this big safety net; it's a credential that makes it easier to get a job later," she said. "Maybe life shouldn't be that way, but it is what it is."
Hi Jeremy,

Actually the way I have explained my professional experience may sound like a switch of fields every time. However essentially my job profile was that of number crunching/data analysis; be it Transportation Consultancy, Market Research or Credit Card industry.

As far as grades are concerned a GPA of 6.24/10.0 should be considered as average.

One point that I would like to mention about my experience is the employee headcount of places where I worked:-

Transportation Consultancy - 10
Market Research - 30-35
Credit Card Company (Present Job) - 10,000+ worldwide

The point I am trying to make here is that I have experienced extremely challenging environments of small companies where you should be more of 'jack of all trades' and should always be on the lookout of opportunities to grow the business. On the other hand now I am learning the in and out of big corporations where there are more heads and more thoughts floating around and how channeling of thoughts become more important for the growth of business.

I am not sure how useful my experience would be for a class that I would join but I thought this worth mentioning to you for your opinion.

Regards,
Vishal
Vishal,
Thanks for your inquiry.
Clearly, your GMAT is quite strong. I have worked with Indian candidates before and know that engineering grades need to be viewed in relative terms, as a 60% can sometimes top the class. So, I would need more information in this regard.
Still, I think that you are going to find it difficult to get that coveted letter of acceptance, due to the fact that you have not only switched jobs but switched fields frequently. While you dont need to remain in one job or field, the schools like to see a clear path and clear upward trajectory. Further, what is it that you think differentiates you from all other Indian candidates, particularly professionally? With such a strong pool, how will you standout and capture the attention of the ultra-selective Admissions Committees at schools like Stanford and Harvard?
I think that LBS is a possibility, but if you are looking to American schools you might consider schools with strong Finance programs that are not as highly ranked NYU and Texas for example. I think that HBS, Chicago and Stanford will be reaches, unless I am missing something significant from your profile.
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBA Mission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype:MBAMission

hi Jeremy,
Many thanks for your insightful and Useful thoughts.
I like to ask couple of qs which i think ill be generic an applicable to all in Indain Context:

Qs 1: You talked about taking extra courses (academically) however i just like to inform
you in Indian education system this thing is not possible and practical currently.
So Ilike to know how Bschools percieve professional certifications like PMP,
APICS , Oracle certification extra?
Qs 2: Regarding 'Community service' what things could be included in this?
In indian context for ex'Teaching basketball team' is not possible.
So is ist mandatory to have community experiece ?
Qs 3: I like to know how the visibility of Indian collegs have it in US/Europe?
Colleges like IIT etc how they are percieved in US/Europe?
Do indain colleges have any impact outside or only grades matter?

Thanks for your time and patience.
eagerly looking forward for another insightful post from you.

Thanks and Regds
HMG

(Well, a post should not exceed 15000 characters, so here is much of the rest in another frame...)

The following is the fourth in a series of postings on preparing for the coming year.
Visiting Campuses and Networking with Students and Alumni
As I have noted in previous posts, it would be ideal for you as a prospective candidate to have nothing but your applications to manage come July (when most .....
........
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
HMG

Thanks for your latest inquiry.

Because you are a technical consultant, the onus will be on you to spend the next few years differentiating yourself via your community activities and personal experiences. If you can gain some extraordinary experience in ERP, it could help, but it is doubtful that you will be able to standout solely on the basis of your work experience. So, you will need to spend the next two years building your shadow resume.

Social entrepreneurship is generally one of the strongest differentiators, but it is somewhat absurd for me to tell you to go out and start your own organization. The bottom line is that you need to be committed to your community activities and show tremendous passion for them, regardless of what the activity might be. There is no single organization that you should join, but whatever you do, you should try to bring true leadership and change the organization for the better (if it needs change). I may have discussed this already, but it is not enough to just go to clean a park each week; you need to be living your experience; you need to imbue your experience with meaning. By joining two organizations that offer different windows into your personality, you can emphasize the differences between you and other candidates.

Similarly, through personal experiences you can differentiate yourself. This can be summed up simply via be as interesting a human being as you can be; live your personal adventure. I am not suggesting that you start a dangerous sea-kayaking expedition tomorrow; I am suggesting that you push your personal limits, try new things and complete ambitious goals that you have set for yourself. Whether you are traveling, learning a language, completing an athletic feat, performing, etc., the process is not as important as the fact that you are living with vitality and that you have a strong commitment to self. Business schools are impressed by those who show leadership in all spheres professional, community and personal. If you can commit yourself to each area during the next two years, you should find yourself sufficiently differentiated and competitive at your schools of choice.

Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBA Mission

www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
hi Jeremy,

My Profile as of now:
Introduction:
Company : India's Top IT company
Years of experience : 3 Years (as of June'06)
Domain: Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) as Technical Consultant in SCM (Supply Chain Management)
International Exposure: 1 Year ( Netherlands). Worked in 4 projects and in various Locations as of Now.
Achievements:
1.Certifications:
a). Project Management Certification from PMI (US)
b). Oracle ERP Certification in SCM track
2. Exceptional Yearly ratings throughout 3 years (5 out of 5)
3. STAR of the Month Award in TCS
4. Oracle Apps CoE (Centre of excellence ) Champion (Its a Group in my company having around 2500 people).
Organization Contribution:(Extra initiatives)
1. Mentoring - (For career planning of New Joiness in our companyin our group)
2. Various Trainings at Corporate level
3. Few white papers
Extracurricular: (During Job)
1. Public Speaking Club
2. Participate in Cultural activities in in my company.
Academics:
1. Both BCA and MCA ( not done from some great college)- Thats the weakest point in my profile.
2. Always In Top 5 in the class both undergrad and Post grad.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Based on above Profile following are my findings:
1. My target colleges - (1 yr MBA) ISB/IIM/Cambridge/Oxford/RSM.
2. Since my academics are not from dome great college I need at least 720 + score in GMAT.
3. I need to work more on My profile add some more 'weightage ' things.
I need to add more things
Now I need your valuable Inputs and insights. Please tell me seeing my above profile:
1. What extra 'weightage ' things I should add to my profile so that I can come in my target colleges (are these target colleges possible with my profile)?
2. I have 1-2 years to add those things in my profile? Is this thinking right? Or am I being too optimistic or too pessimistic.
3. What else I can do? Have you seen people not from so good colleges entering Ivy colleges ?
I know with above above profile aiming for top 10 colleges is foolishness? (is this thinking right?)
I know you are very busy and have loads of other work to do.
But I will be grateful if you can took out some time and send your valuable inputs to me.
Thanks..

HMG
Dev,

Thanks for your inquiry.

Official involvement as you note is important, but the committee is not looking solely for organizational involvement. The bottom line is that they want to see leadership and altruism and if this comes via being an active member of CRY or by taking your elderly neighbor shopping and spending time with him/her because he/she is in need, both are fine. The spirit and intensity of your actions is far more important than the notoriety of your organization. If you were unusually dedicated to tutoring juniors in college, mentoring freshers at workplace and giving reiki treatments while at work then you will have some interesting altruistic/human stories to tell, I am sure.
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBA Mission

www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
Hi Jeremy,

First of all thanks for volunteering on PG! We certainly needed some expert guidance like what you have on BW forums. I am sure you would enjoy posting here.

I had one question about this community service thing. I understand that most of the B Schools specifically ask for the names of communities/social-clubs etc that one has been involved in. I know its good to be officially invloved in such activites because it becomes easier to convince the adcom, but what if one is not.

For instance, I was a rotarian in high school but could never carry on with it in college and later in job. But this doesnt mean that I wasnt taking up social work. Like I was tutoring my juniors in college, mentoring freshers at workplace and giving reiki treatments while at work. Unfortunately none of this was on an official basis.

I have been travelling quite extensively and that is another reason (or excuse ;-)) for not being commited to socially relevant work. Having realised this shortcoming I have started working with a few NGOs in Houston. I would be applying for fall'07 and I am worried that this might prove to be my achilles' heel.

Any Suggestions?
I am not at all concerned about my acads/wrk exp/gmat. I know I wud sail thru in those areas.

Regards,
Dev

Jeremy,

That was truly insightful and answered all my questions.Thank you for your time.

V

Thanks for your inquiry.
You wrote 2.9/3, did you mean 2.9/4? Still, even if your GPA is low, that was eight years ago and you could make the case that there are better indicators with regard to your abilities and capacity for future success (recommendations, GMAT, etc.)
Your age is an obstacle, but there is nothing that you can do about this, so you will have to work with it. You will have to emphasize your experience as a decision maker and your international experience in East Africa; in simple terms, you will need to show that you are not applying because you are bored and old, but that you are applying now because your career was fascinating, you were a leader and you did not have time to take a breath until now.
Similarly, you should have very clear goals going forward you need to make clear that your best years are ahead of you and that this MBA will make your future goals a reality. More so than with younger candidates, you will really need to have vision and ambition. You cant get away with I want to go into General Management. It is just too vague; the school would rather invest in a younger candidate who has the time to climb the ranks.
I think that Stanford is unrealistic for you and Yale, with its small class, might be quite difficult as well. You might find a spot at Darden or Fuqua, but this really depends on how much leadership you have had in your workplace and whether you can wow the adcom with these experiences.
Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission
www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission

Hello jeremy,
Thanks for you all useful inputs. It has given me some very important pointers
to work on.
I will be grateful if you can reply 2 of my questions:
Qs 1. How muc weighatge does US/European B schools give to Indian undergrad schools. Does they prefer student from some india undergrad school or only grades matter (whatever indian udergrad college it will be) ?

Qs 2. I am Master's In computer Application (MCA) ? will it any way go in my favour or against it?

Thanks for your replies

Regds
HMG

Thanks for your inquiry. I must admit that I am not sure what you are asking me for in the first part of your question FAQs and essays?

In terms of your question about programs that are the best for banking, virtually all of the top fifteen schools are very well-connected to the global financial markets. The schools that are perceived to be Finance Schools are Wharton, Chicago, Columbia and NYU, but you certainly would not go wrong with HBS, Stanford, Kellogg, MIT, Michigan, Darden, Tuck, Cornell and others. The latter schools are not as finance focused, but definitely can connect you to the major financial institutions.

Sincerely,
Jeremy Shinewald
MBAMission

www.mbamission.com
646-485-8844
Skype: MBAMission
Hi Jeremy,

Well this time the set of Q's pertain to SOP's/Essay part ( I already posted these queries on other thread & as I was not able to get answer there, I am seeking your help, puys pl bare with me :satisfie:).... Of the research ,which I have done, most b school have a diffrent set of questoins.. but then you are alomost sure to find ..

:snipersm:Why an MBA ?
:snipersm:Why this B School ?
:snipersm:SWOT analysis..
:snipersm:examples of team role, leadeship ,blah blah...

You might think its too early but the problem is that my Boss (who knows my plans) has already told me that you dare not move your butt out of my seat in Sep-oct :bad-word:)... So I wanted to be sure that I have worked on some of the basic question & qualities that I need to bring out along with instances from real life (in the essay's/Sop)... I know answer has to be modified from one b school to the other, but the basic structure would be the same ...??:??:!!??

So I request you to provide me a with FAQ's/Essays . So that I could prepare a skeleton well in advance and I dont sc**w up my essay's in a hurry in sep-oct....

Thankx in advance.

Azeem

PS:- which are the best MBA programmes world wide for Investment Banking ?? (pl Provide me with a list of them)

Subscribing to the thread

Thanks Jeremy for volunteering to help PG members

cheers

hi Jeremy,

I have got an admit frm ICMA Center- University of Reading , UK . The course is MSc- International Securities Investement and Banking.

I am interested in finance and a fresh graduate from Engineering stream with average acads.

Please enlighten me about the course and wat is its scope as far as job in UK goes.

waiting for ur reply,

Regards,
Sanjay Kathuria