abhishekrehan Sayshey guys i too have converted sibm-p... one querry..should I even think of attending the NMIMS interview now? Nmims vs SIBM.. what do y ou all feel?
De de bhai agar Mumbai Campus ka hai .
De de bhai agar Mumbai Campus ka hai .
@shouryasen :: What is the pre-induction program?
akshay1406 Says@shouryasen :: What is the pre-induction program?
It is a programme designed to help aspirants such as yourself get better accustomed to b-school life and acads...
you will be sent materials via courier and this online programme will test you each week with quizzes, assignments and tests....
it is made so that everyone is in-sync when they come on campus....
it is a heads up on the kinds of subjects that will be taught once on campus and the course load as such....
This online programme might/might not be graded as a part of your course gpa in order to better align you with acads here on campus...
Cheers!!
@shourya, the selection is like '180 selected + 100's waitlist' or are there any buffer calls with those selected 180.. b'cause few institutes follow the method of giving buffer calls..an 'm rejected..:banghead: so asking this ques..
at general WL 60 are there any chances?
got thru!!
category KM.
raMBrAm Says@shourya, the selection is like '180 selected + 100's waitlist' or are there any buffer calls with those selected 180.. b'cause few institutes follow the method of giving buffer calls..an 'm rejected..:banghead: so asking this ques..
Yes it is as you mentioned formerly.... it is "108 selected + 100 waitlist" IN CASE OF GENERAL CATEGORY...
remember we do not have 180 seats for general category...
108 is general and the rest are categories....
guravus Saysat general WL 60 are there any chances?
Yes you do have a definite fighting chance my friend... but you need to be a bit patient and wait and watch as to how the waitlist movement unfolds...
If i go by last year's trend... you should get a convert call sometime end april...
All the best!!
Cheers!!!
Yes waitlists are separate for each category...
with #20, you can be very hopeful of a final convert real soon....
All the best!!
Cheers!!
Wow!! Thats sounds gud..
Thanks!! Can you tell me how long is the WL for SC gategory ?
Congrats to all those who have converted:clap:
Those in the waiting ,please hang on.
Guys plz dont compare colleges on pg.I knw this is the first result and everyone wants to knw where else to go for interview and where not to ,
but questions like is college X better than SIBM -P cant be handles here.
pk46 SaysWow!! Thats sounds gud..Thanks!! Can you tell me how long is the WL for SC gategory ?
I do not have any clue as to the waitlist count for any category....
Ask your fellow aspirants on this thread and you might get an idea as to the number...
Cheers!!
OK
I'm at WL 80, Open Category !!
What I gather from the thread is itne peeche in WL one needs to wait till IIMs/IITs give out their results ie April-May, chalo koi naa....convert toh ho!!
@shourya, you have been a REALhelp bro, THANKS ALOT!!
@Converts: PARTYYY!!
@WL candidates: yar if any movement is there lets track it, till now 3 ppl have confirmed on thread about not joining ATB to every1 !!!
Well, to begin my post i say i am dejected firstly at being rejected and secondly at SIBM pune.
I see a lot of ambiguities in the process followed by them.
Firstly the institutes follow different procedures for admission.Now as i expect majority of the people selected for SIBM pune who have appeared for SCMHRD will appear in that list also (list expected by 25th). Thus people will be overlapped.Why not have a combined result announcement process.
Secondly the declaration of the result.Why is the consolidated list not given out to the students.What is refraining you from publishing everyone's scores in the individual area's. I tried but coudnt think of a valid reason.It is nothing but will bring in a lot more transparency into the system.
Thirdly the retention of the 30K. There is a rule which says the institute should not keep more than 1K after withdrawal of admission.Why is this workaround for the supposedly "Online Educational Material". If it has cost so much that it cost 30K for every copy generated.
Lastly please don't consider this as a post of someone who has been rejected.Just look it in the wider sense.I guess the questions hold true for people irrespective whether they have converted or wait-listed or rejected.
Replies, Groans and suggestions accepted.
Thanks
Sumit
Well, to begin my post i say i am dejected firstly at being rejected and secondly at SIBM pune.
I see a lot of ambiguities in the process followed by them.
Firstly the institutes follow different procedures for admission.Now as i expect majority of the people selected for SIBM pune who have appeared for SCMHRD will appear in that list also (list expected by 25th). Thus people will be overlapped.Why not have a combined result announcement process.
Secondly the declaration of the result.Why is the consolidated list not given out to the students.What is refraining you from publishing everyone's scores in the individual area's. I tried but coudnt think of a valid reason.It is nothing but will bring in a lot more transparency into the system.
Thirdly the retention of the 30K. There is a rule which says the institute should not keep more than 1K after withdrawal of admission.Why is this workaround for the supposedly "Online Educational Material". If it has cost so much that it cost 30K for every copy generated.
Lastly please don't consider this as a post of someone who has been rejected.Just look it in the wider sense.I guess the questions hold true for people irrespective whether they have converted or wait-listed or rejected.
Replies, Groans and suggestions accepted.
Thanks
Sumit
Look bro, the concept of why the diff symbi colleges dont come out wid a single list doesn't hold water for the simple reason that they are diff colleges! This is true for the IIMs as well, so u cant really fault them.
I do agree with the point abt the 30 k cut. Thats unreasonable.
I made it to the final list of SIBM Pune. I would like to thank all the seniors for being so cooperative throughout the entire process. I can't wait to set my stride into the hallowed portals of SIBM-Pune.
Special Thanks to seniors here @PG Shourya Sen, satana and my GC Nikhil Chitlangia and seniors I met @CWS-Bglr Pratap.
Well, to begin my post i say i am dejected firstly at being rejected and secondly at SIBM pune.
I see a lot of ambiguities in the process followed by them.
Firstly the institutes follow different procedures for admission.Now as i expect majority of the people selected for SIBM pune who have appeared for SCMHRD will appear in that list also (list expected by 25th). Thus people will be overlapped.Why not have a combined result announcement process.
Secondly the declaration of the result.Why is the consolidated list not given out to the students.What is refraining you from publishing everyone's scores in the individual area's. I tried but coudnt think of a valid reason.It is nothing but will bring in a lot more transparency into the system.
Thirdly the retention of the 30K. There is a rule which says the institute should not keep more than 1K after withdrawal of admission.Why is this workaround for the supposedly "Online Educational Material". If it has cost so much that it cost 30K for every copy generated.
Lastly please don't consider this as a post of someone who has been rejected.Just look it in the wider sense.I guess the questions hold true for people irrespective whether they have converted or wait-listed or rejected.
Replies, Groans and suggestions accepted.
Thanks
Sumit
This 30,000 is a real pain.It takes up an entire month's salary, can we register a case for this 😃
First Reject of the season 
Hopefully the last!!!!
Well, to begin my post i say i am dejected firstly at being rejected and secondly at SIBM pune.
I see a lot of ambiguities in the process followed by them.
Firstly the institutes follow different procedures for admission.Now as i expect majority of the people selected for SIBM pune who have appeared for SCMHRD will appear in that list also (list expected by 25th). Thus people will be overlapped.Why not have a combined result announcement process.
Secondly the declaration of the result.Why is the consolidated list not given out to the students.What is refraining you from publishing everyone's scores in the individual area's. I tried but coudnt think of a valid reason.It is nothing but will bring in a lot more transparency into the system.
Thirdly the retention of the 30K. There is a rule which says the institute should not keep more than 1K after withdrawal of admission.Why is this workaround for the supposedly "Online Educational Material". If it has cost so much that it cost 30K for every copy generated.
Lastly please don't consider this as a post of someone who has been rejected.Just look it in the wider sense.I guess the questions hold true for people irrespective whether they have converted or wait-listed or rejected.
Replies, Groans and suggestions accepted.
Thanks
Sumit
SIBM and SCMHRD are two separate colleges under the SIU.
It is ur assumption that there will be a lot of overlaps between the two.In any case there are a lot of overlaps between SIBM and other colleges too.
Its akin to asking all IIMs having a common list.But with colleges being different ,why should the result be common.
At this point i cant comment on your second question.
As soon as i get some more information i ll definitely post it on the thread.
regarding the pre induction course ware , I understand that 30 k may appear steep, but the courseware is designed by SIBM -P and it is its intellectual property.Had it been simple books published by other publications that the college would have provided the question would have been valid.Those who will not join SIBM ,I would suggest , read the material well.It ill help u immensely where ever you go.
My first covert!!!!
Thanks a lot all the seniors... especially Shourya and satana!!!!
Big congrats Sid:clap:
regarding the pre induction course ware , I understand that 30 k may appear steep, but the courseware is designed by SIBM -P and it is its intellectual property.Had it been simple books published by other publications that the college would have provided the question would have been valid.Those who will not join SIBM ,I would suggest , read the material well.It ill help u immensely where ever you go.
If that is the case you should have given the candidates a choice of joining the pre induction course.This is really unfair.
Firstly, don't question the selection criteria of an institute, I think the institute knows best what they are looking for. The fact that they do not come out with common admission list for different colleges is because each institute within the university is a separate entity and thus following separate admission procedures. Look at it this way, how can they come up with the common list when many of the applicants would not have even applied to many colleges and maybe applied to only SIBM-P. If they wanted a combined list, we would have gone through just one GD/PI process which is not the case.
I don't think many institutes display the actual marks scored by a candidate in various components of the process, still RTI is always an option I think.
I agree to your point regarding the 30K for pre-induction fee which is uncalled for. I don't think the material costs anywhere close to that and most of the things will be done online as stated by Shourya. Even I don't like this pre-induction process, looks more like a commercial move.
Thanks