• Home
  • News
  • Forums
    • CAT & related B-schools
    • XAT, SNAP, IIFT, MAT, CMAT   and related B-schools
    • CAT: Quant Prep
    • CAT: Verbal Prep
    • CAT: GK & other resources
    • GMAT & GRE prep
    • GMAT accepting B-schools
    • Jobs & Careers
    • Pre-MBA Jobs
    • Post-MBA Jobs
    • Chit-Chat
    • PG-Meets & Events
    • Life @ B-schools
    • Touching Lives
  • Apps
    • Townhall
    • Badges
    • Birthdays
  • Rankings
 

Messages

Send a New Message
View All

Notifications

View All

Karma Updates

View All
    Live Ticker
    Login
    • Forgot password?

    New to PaGaLGuY?

    Login ×

    New to PaGaLGuY? Sign Up!

    Login

    Login
    Forgot your password/username?

    Forgot your password? ×

    Advertisements
    Advertisements
    GD out, excellent communication skills and case-study analysis in at NMIMS
    by Lajwanti D'Souza in NMIMS, NMAT 2013, admission criteria changes on 13 July '12

    SVKMs Narsee Monjee Institute of Management Studies (NMIMS), is going to herald in big changes in its admission process for the 2013 batch. Besides doing away with the conventional 'Group Discussion' (GD), it is planning to introduce additional elements in its online entrance test - NMIMS Management Aptitude Test (NMAT) 2013.

    Speaking exclusively to PaGaLGuY.com, Dr. Rajan Saxena, Vice-Chancellor, NMIMS, said that the institute has been experimenting with the GD for two years and this year the changes will be cemented. "We moved away from the typical GD method and introduced the case-study one. We have seen over the years that a traditional GD throws up the same set of students.Those that come in after getting trained at coaching institutes. They all behave and speak in an expected manner. We wanted individual capabilities to come to the fore and the case study method allows it," said Dr Saxena.

    In this rather different kind of a GD, aspirants are given a case study to analyse and then discuss." This method, helps us unearth characteristics such as logical thinking, decision-making, leadership and data analysis qualities in the aspirants," added Dr Saxena.

    Additionally, the term 'GD' will also meet its end this year and a new term, something on the lines of 'Case-study discussion' will be used at NMIMS.
    Another big decision that NMIMS has taken, is to look at communication skills of applicants more keenly." We believe that proper and efficient communication skills are very important to excel in corporate life and we will particularly look at them when admitting students," added Dr Saxena.
    One more big shift that NMIMS is working on is to add an 'ethical' dimension to the written test. "We have not fully thought through it but we are speaking to Pearson VUE. The plan is to test candidates on ethical decision making. Aspirants will be given typical corporate problems and asked to take hypothetical ethical decisions ." Dr Saxena disclosed.
    It is the same story everywhere. B-schools tweaking admission procedures to increase diversity (read more non-engineers and women candidates.) "Next year we will come up with some more changes in the exam pattern to bring in additional diversity," hinted the Vice-chancellor.
    Registrations from NMAT 2013 have opened. Like last year, students will be be able to take the online test in a window period of about one and a half months from October 11 to December 19, 2012 with a choice of two retakes. In the cases of retakes, the best of three scores shall be considered for admissions to all the MBa programmes by the NMIMS institute at its Mumbai, Bengaluru & Hyderabad Campuses. NMAT 2013 will be conducted at 18 centers across the country.
    • Reply
    • Like 80
    • Share 9
    • Follow
    dhruvwali, aakd & 78 others like this
    vivekimmortal, kalyani49 & 7 others shared this shared this
    • Page 1 of 5  
    • ank_mission_IIM I think hypothetical ethical decisions should be part of every management test....these questions also help in testing candidates psychologicaly...
      #1 • 12 Jul '12 Like 2
    • sushantvit Now this (section on ethics)can be called an appropriate change for increasing diversity instead of forcing it.
      #2 • 12 Jul '12 Like 21
    • lucky_ali GD is 'General Discussion'? Didn't know that!
      #3 • 12 Jul '12 Like 1
    • Abhishek090 yeah case study thing has already been implemented in various b-school entrance procedure.....one of them is K J somaiya
      #4 • 12 Jul '12 Like 1
    • Anuprati It's good to know about it,as the process of flitering students will become more finer in NMIMS.
      #5 • 12 Jul '12 Like 1
    • Dhiresh1009 well, good changes, i feel... all three changes combined should bring in students with more holistic skill sets..
      #6 • 12 Jul '12 Like 2
    • Raditz Sounds good, so what will the new paper pattern be like?
      #7 • 12 Jul '12 Like
    • pratewari What does 2013 mean here? Is this not for the candidates taking NMAT this year?
      #8 • 12 Jul '12 Like
    • pavsandy13 good changes ................:)
      #9 • 12 Jul '12 Like
    • mbajamesbond i like it...much needed
      #10 • 12 Jul '12 Like
    • rahulrevenger Thumbs Up, Sounds Rational
      #11 • 12 Jul '12 Like
    • gs4890 All set for the change :)
      #12 • 12 Jul '12 Like
    • shivs Finally GD exits ... A good decision though ...!!!! :)
      #13 • 12 Jul '12 Like 1
    • champa It only sounds good, what they think, can't the coaching centres help students prepare case studies ,basically what NM want is money, money and more money
      #14 • 12 Jul '12 Like 6
    • Kushwaha really good article. seems other institutions will follow too.
      #15 • 12 Jul '12 Like
    • onceagainimback One test with two retakes, Now NMIMS is nothing more but aimcats ,seek your best performance. Thanks ICC is not implementing this, one batsman can takes two retake once he outs at low.
      #16 • 13 Jul '12 Like 1
    • isharma Can i get any example of what kind of case study can come ??
      #17 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • MrSherlock Are engineers bad managers?? what is this hype of non-engineer all about, i don't understand :(
      #18 • 13 Jul '12 Like 20
    • immortals does ethical delimma is similar to decision making as asked in XAT
      #19 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • cricaddict @immortals : Ethical Dilemma being discussed will be very much similar to XAT DM ....

      This seems to be a good move to bring in diversity now don't read Non-Engg and Females, it can be diversity of people with diff mindset and perspective and unlike belief of all B-Schools in India 1 Engg can be completely diff from another Engg.. There is no need to generalise them..
      #20 • 13 Jul '12 Like 2
    • Page 2 of 5  
    • shendenishant99 Why is everyone against males and engineers????
      #21 • 13 Jul '12 Like 8
    • sushantvit @shendenishant99 Because supply(of GEMs)>demand,so we GEMS come CHEAP and people don't like cheap things in their (board)rooms. PS: I'm a GEM and i understood the benefits of having diversity after entering a b-school.
      #22 • 13 Jul '12 Like 2
    • shrikantj Change is good...!!!
      #23 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • cynicall changes in written test (decision making etc) are for NMAT 2012 or 2013...? can author throw some light on it.
      #24 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • cynicall @author I don't think these changes in written are for this year test as the syllabus for the written test is out on the NMAT site and there is no mention of these changes.. Can author plz clear this confusion


      #25 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • abhiravi actually the paper is conducted in every year jan-feb window so they are telling 2013!!!
      #26 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • iamniks The ethical reasoning part seems to be a change for the better...!!!
      #27 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • anisha04 it is gud dat GD finally exits... case study would be a more practical way for filtering students
      #28 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • Nipunkumar Um I got a call from NMIMS Mumbai for 2012-14 batch, and it was a case study based GD only. I don't see the difference, just the change in name. The moderator had to stop our GD twice, and then re start. No one made any sense, still managed to convert MBA Banking and MBA Capital Markets. :)
      Hoping to convert Core this year. But I really don't see any difference besides the name.
      #29 • 13 Jul '12 Like 3
    • aabhishekbindal really a good appreciable change in the selection criteria..:)
      #30 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • Taloola Sorry, it is totally different I just want to know that do we need to pay again for re-test or not ?
      #31 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • PujaKeshri I want to know which is better for NMIMS PGDM Bengaluru or Hyderabad? and please also tell me which is better MBA or PGDM?
      #32 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • maansidevi " with a choice of two retakes. In the cases of retakes, the best of three scores shall be considered for admissions to all the MBa programmes "

      (y)
      #33 • 13 Jul '12 Like
    • aabhishekbindal NMIMS PGDM Benguluru is much better.
      #34 • 13 Jul '12 Like 1
    • ashish21may Are U people really fed Up from the engineers....? If yes, then go back to past and see that the place where ur college stands today is Bcauz of past results which is given By students and majority of them were ENGINEERS.... So stop this Clamoring about diversity....
      Yours ..
      An ENGINEER
      #35 • 14 Jul '12 Like 1
    • smcetguy engineers rock
      #36 • 14 Jul '12 Like 3
    • preetyangel sounds not so gud !!!!!!!!!.....:(
      #37 • 14 Jul '12 Like
    • devenkvyas U could put Unlike Button too in NEW LOOK :D
      #38 • 15 Jul '12 Like
    • jitrana where's is the 'money' angle behind this decicion!!
      #39 • 15 Jul '12 Like
    • KnowledgeMine In my honest opinion, the way some B-Schools are "forcing" changes in their system to accomodate more female candidates and non-engineers may not appear fair towards engineers, but it is a good step nevertheless.

      The discussions so far have been on how crucial it is to get more diversity in the batches, and yet the flawed examination systems still remain intact... Even to this date CAT does not have a section on General Awareness and Decision Making, ditto for NMAT. XAT, SNAP and IIFT have more balanced papers, if not totally perfect.

      So, in papers like CAT where mathematics forms an important part, engineers are bound to excel. But one needs to be fair to engineers too. How is it an engineers fault that he is good at maths?

      The goal should not be to exclude engineers to accomodate more non-engineers, rather to test many different aspects of a person's intellect and thinking. One needs to be fair to engineers too you know... :)
      #40 • 15 Jul '12 Like 9
    • B I U
      Press Shift+Enter to add a new line.

    • © 2013 PaGaLGuY
    • About Us
    • Careers
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Help
    • Privacy
    Report This Content ×

    Your report does not guarantee removal of this content from the site. It will be removed altogether only if a Moderator finds it especially useless after reviewing it.

    Warn User

    ×

    Repeal a Warning

    ×

    Promote this post

    ×
    web04:8065